Best Cigar Punch: Top Picks for 2024

Justin R.
Justin R.

Cigar Enthusiast, Chief Editor

best cigar punch
Table of Contents

A cigar punch is an essential tool for any cigar smoker. It is a small, handheld device that creates a small hole in the cap of a cigar, allowing for a smooth and even draw.

Cigar punches come in a variety of styles and sizes, and choosing the best one can be a daunting task.

When selecting a cigar punch, there are a few critical things to consider. The first is the size of the punch. A small punch will create a small hole and a less substantial draw, while a larger punch will create a larger hole and a more substantial draw.

The second is the material of the punch. A metal punch will be more durable but may be more challenging to clean, while a plastic punch will be more lightweight and easy to clean.

After researching and testing various cigar punches, I have identified the top five best cigar punches on the market. These punches stand out for their ease of use, durability, and ability to create a smooth and even draw.

Whether you are a seasoned cigar smoker or a beginner, one of these punches is sure to meet your needs.

Best Cigar Punches

As a cigar aficionado, I know firsthand the importance of having the right tools for the job. One essential tool for any cigar smoker is a good cigar punch.

A cigar punch provides a clean cut to the cap of your cigar, allowing for a smooth and even draw. After extensive research and testing, I have compiled a list of the best cigar punches on the market.

Whether you’re a seasoned smoker or just starting out, these punches are sure to enhance your smoking experience.

TISFA Cigar Punch Cutter

TISFA Cigar Punch Cutter

If you’re looking for a compact and portable cigar punch that is easy to carry around, then the TISFA Cigar Punch Cutter is worth considering.

Pros

  • The TISFA Cigar Punch Cutter is made of high-quality stainless steel, which makes it durable and anti-rust.
  • It is compact and portable, which makes it easy to carry around in your pocket or attach it to your backpack or luggage.
  • The TISFA Cigar Punch Cutter is user-friendly, with a sharp standard gauge punch that cuts an 8mm hole onto any cigar perfectly.

Cons

  • The TISFA Cigar Punch Cutter may be too small for some people’s fingers to get used to.
  • The circular puncher may not be suitable for all types of cigars, especially those with a larger ring gauge.
  • The TISFA Cigar Punch Cutter may not be as effective as other cigar punches on the market.

I recently tried the TISFA Cigar Punch Cutter and was impressed with its durability and compact design. The puncher is sharp and cuts a perfect hole onto any cigar.

It’s also easy to screw out parts piece to expose the circular puncher and features a push button to remove any cigar leaf after each use.

The TISFA Cigar Punch Cutter looks simple but classy, with a simple black color that matches any apparel. It’s a great decoration for your bag, briefcase, or even as a keychain.

The cigar punch is packed in a box and can be used as a gift for cigar aficionados.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for a compact and portable cigar punch that is easy to carry around and use, then the TISFA Cigar Punch Cutter is a great option to consider.

FANKAI 4 Torch Jet Flame Cigar Lighter with Punch, Draw Enhancer, Refillable Windproof Lighter, Cigar Accessories and Gift Box Gray

FANKAI 4 Torch Jet Flame Cigar Lighter with Punch, Draw Enhancer, Refillable Windproof Lighter, Cigar Accessories and Gift Box Gray

If you are looking for a versatile and feature-packed cigar lighter, the FANKAI 4 Torch Jet Flame Cigar Lighter with Punch, Draw Enhancer, Refillable Windproof Lighter, Cigar Accessories and Gift Box Gray is an excellent choice.

Pros

  • The four jet blue fire ensures a quick and even light for your cigars.
  • The windproof design makes it suitable for use indoors and outdoors.
  • The cigar holder on the top safe lid avoids bringing an extra cigar stand when you’re outside.

Cons

  • The cigar holder may not be suitable for cigars with a diameter greater than 20mm.
  • The lighter may be heavier than other cigar lighters.
  • The lighter may not work properly if not used for an extended period.

I recently purchased the FANKAI 4 Torch Jet Flame Cigar Lighter with Punch, Draw Enhancer, Refillable Windproof Lighter, Cigar Accessories and Gift Box Gray and was impressed with its high-pressure fire-breathing technology.

The flame is concentrated, strong, and powerful, igniting my cigar in just a few seconds. The windproof design made it easy to use both indoors and outdoors.

The cigar holder on the top safe lid was a convenient feature, and the length and width of the holder were suitable for cigars with a diameter below 20mm.

I also appreciated the foldable cigar punch with its stainless steel sharp blade, which provided a clean and perfect cut every time.

The mini cigar draw enhancer tool was another useful feature, with its barbed design of the needle easily solving the problem of overfilling and clogging of cigars, making the smooth airflow of smoking more enjoyable.

The FANKAI 4 Torch Jet Flame Cigar Lighter with Punch, Draw Enhancer, Refillable Windproof Lighter, Cigar Accessories and Gift Box Gray is made of premium zinc alloy material.

Drawing craft, and electroplating polishing, making it sturdy, wear-resistant, and high-temperature resistant. The weight of the lighter is 125 grams, and it comes with an elegant gift box, making it an ideal gift for cigar enthusiasts.

In conclusion, if you are looking for a versatile and feature-packed cigar lighter, the FANKAI 4 Torch Jet Flame Cigar Lighter with Punch, Draw Enhancer, Refillable Windproof Lighter, Cigar Accessories and Gift Box Gray is an excellent choice.

XIFEI Cigar Drill Sharp Smooth Blade Creative Portable Cigar Draw Enhancer Cigar Punch (Black)

XIFEI Cigar Punch

This cigar punch is a great addition to any cigar enthusiast’s collection. It is easy to use, portable, and made of high-quality materials.

Pros

  • The dual-use cigar tool is sharp and easy to use.
  • Made of copper and stainless steel, the cigar drill is durable and long-lasting.
  • The XIFEI service is excellent and responsive to any questions or concerns.

Cons

  • The punch creates a larger hole than some other cigar punches, which may not be suitable for smaller cigars.
  • It may take some practice to learn how to twist the tool to use the punch effectively.
  • The tool is a bit heavy and may not be as portable as some other cigar punches.

Overall, I would recommend this cigar punch for anyone looking for a durable and effective tool to enhance their cigar experience. The dual-use design and high-quality materials make it a great choice.

Pardo 4-in-1 Cigar Multitool

Pardo 4-in-1 Cigar Multitool

If you’re looking for a versatile cigar tool that can do it all, the Pardo 4-in-1 Cigar Multitool is a great option.

Pros

  • The dual cigar punch cutter is perfect for any size ring gauge cigar, with an 8mm punch for small and medium ring gauges and an 11mm punch for large 60+ ring gauges.
  • The cigar draw tool is a great solution for overfilled, tight, or plugged cigars, providing the perfect airflow and draw with the draw poker.
  • The twin cigar nubber is a superior cigar holder that allows you to enjoy your cigar all the way to the nub.

Cons

  • The retractable punches are sharp, so adult supervision is necessary when using them.
  • The nub tool leaves a 1/4″ sharp point exposed when removed for use, which can be annoying if kept in your pocket.
  • The punches can be finicky and may require some practice to use properly.

I recently used the Pardo 4-in-1 Cigar Multitool and was impressed with its versatility and quality. The compact design makes it easy to stow in your pocket, golf bag, or car, and the durable construction ensures that it will last for years to come.

The dual cigar punch cutter is a standout feature, with two sizes to accommodate any size ring gauge cigar. The cigar draw tool is also a great addition, providing the perfect airflow and draw with the draw poker.

And the twin cigar nubber is a superior cigar holder that allows you to enjoy your cigar all the way to the nub.

While the retractable punches are sharp, they are easy to use once you get the hang of them. And while the nub tool can be annoying when kept in your pocket, it’s a minor issue compared to the overall quality of the tool.

Overall, if you’re looking for a versatile cigar tool that can do it all, the Pardo 4-in-1 Cigar Multitool is a great option.

CIGARLOONG Cigar Punch Double Blade Sharp Size Drill Cigar Hole Opener Cutter Gold3

CIGARLOONG Cigar Punch

If you’re looking for a reliable and stylish cigar punch, the CIGARLOONG Cigar Punch Double Blade Sharp Size Drill Cigar Hole Opener Cutter Gold3 is definitely worth considering.

Pros

  • The carving process makes it easy to handle and provides a better feel.
  • The retro pattern gives it a personalized touch.
  • The screw open feature allows for easy use.

Cons

  • The dual rotating punches can become problematic and slice your hand.
  • The Loctite retaining compound can restrict use to only one side.
  • The double drill may not be suitable for all cigar sizes.

I recently purchased this cigar punch and was impressed by its sharp blades that easily cut into the cigar without damaging the wrapper.

The screw open feature made it easy to use, and the retro pattern added a touch of personality to my cigar accessories.

However, I did run into some issues with the dual rotating punches. The bottom punch would rotate open when using the other side, which could lead to slicing your hand.

I found that using Loctite retaining compound solved this problem, but it did restrict use to only one side. Additionally, the double drill may not be suitable for all cigar sizes.

Overall, I would recommend the CIGARLOONG Cigar Punch Double Blade Sharp Size Drill Cigar Hole Opener Cutter Gold3 to anyone looking for a reliable and stylish cigar punch.

HAWAN Cigar Punch 4 in 1 Multitool Dual Size Punch with Draw Enhancer Cutter and Twin Nubber

HAWAN Cigar Punch 4 in 1 Multitool Dual Size Punch with Draw Enhancer Cutter and Twin Nubber

If you’re looking for an all-in-one tool for your cigar needs, the HAWAN Cigar Punch is definitely worth considering. It’s a multitool that features a dual size punch with draw enhancer cutter and twin nubber.

The tool is made of stainless steel and comes in a gift box.

Pros

  • The dual size punch allows you to choose the perfect size for your cigar.
  • The draw enhancer ensures a better draw, making your smoking experience more enjoyable.
  • The tool is made of high-quality stainless steel, ensuring durability and longevity.

Cons

  • The cutter heads don’t pop up easily, so you need to make sure they are fully retracted to avoid accidental cutting.
  • The tool is a bit heavy, which may not be ideal for some users who prefer a lighter tool.
  • The price point is a bit higher than some other cigar punches on the market.

Overall, I would recommend the HAWAN Cigar Punch to anyone looking for a high-quality, all-in-one tool for their cigar needs.

The dual size punch, draw enhancer, and twin nubber make it a versatile tool that can enhance your cigar smoking experience.

The only downsides are the weight and price point, but the tool’s durability and functionality make it worth the investment.

In my experience, the tool has been easy to use and has performed well. The dual size punch ensures that I can use it on any cigar, and the draw enhancer has definitely improved the draw on some of my tighter cigars.

The twin nubber is also a nice feature that allows me to hold my cigar without burning my fingers.

Overall, I’m happy with my purchase of the HAWAN Cigar Punch and would recommend it to any cigar enthusiast looking for a versatile tool.

Buying Guide

When it comes to choosing the best cigar punch, there are several factors to consider. Here are some key features to look for when shopping for a cigar punch:

Material

The material of the cigar punch can affect its durability and performance. Stainless steel and titanium are popular choices for their strength and resistance to corrosion.

Some cigar punches are made of brass or aluminum, which can be lighter in weight and less expensive.

Size

Cigar punches come in different sizes, and the size you choose will depend on your personal preference and the size of your cigars. A smaller punch may be more convenient for travel, while a larger punch may be more comfortable to hold and use.

Shape

The shape of the cigar punch can affect its ease of use and the size of the hole it creates. Some punches have a cylindrical shape, while others are conical or have a V-shape.

A punch with a wider opening may be more suitable for larger cigars, while a punch with a narrower opening may be better for smaller cigars.

Features

Some cigar punches come with additional features, such as a keychain attachment or a retractable blade. These features can add convenience and versatility to your cigar punch, but they may also increase the cost.

By considering these factors, you can choose a cigar punch that meets your needs and preferences. Remember to choose a high-quality product from a reputable manufacturer to ensure the best performance and longevity.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the benefits of using a cigar punch compared to a traditional cutter?

Using a cigar punch instead of a traditional cutter has several benefits. First, a cigar punch creates a small hole in the cap of the cigar, which allows for a more concentrated flow of smoke. This can enhance the flavor and aroma of the cigar.

Second, a cigar punch reduces the risk of damaging the wrapper of the cigar, which can affect the burn and draw of the cigar.

Finally, a cigar punch is generally more compact and portable than a traditional cutter, making it a convenient tool for cigar enthusiasts on the go.

How do you determine the appropriate size for a cigar punch?

The appropriate size for a cigar punch depends on the size of the cigar you plan to smoke. A small punch, with a diameter of around 6mm, is suitable for cigars with a ring gauge of up to 40.

A medium punch, with a diameter of around 9mm, is suitable for cigars with a ring gauge of up to 50. A large punch, with a diameter of around 12mm, is suitable for cigars with a ring gauge of up to 60.

It is important to choose a punch that matches the size of your cigar to ensure a proper draw.

Which luxury cigar punches offer the best quality and craftsmanship?

There are several luxury cigar punches on the market that offer exceptional quality and craftsmanship. Some of the top brands include Davidoff, S.T. Dupont, and Xikar.

These brands use high-quality materials and precision engineering to create durable and reliable cigar punches.

While these punches may be more expensive than other options, they are worth the investment for serious cigar enthusiasts who demand the best.

What are the top-rated cigar punches available on Amazon?

There are many highly-rated cigar punches available on Amazon. Some of the top-rated options include the Xikar Xi2 Punch, the Colibri V-Cut Cigar Cutter, and the ALASKA BEAR – Cigar Punch.

These punches have received positive reviews from customers for their durability, ease of use, and effectiveness.

Can you recommend a cigar punch that provides great value for the price?

One cigar punch that provides great value for the price is the Mantello Cigar Punch. This punch is made from stainless steel and features a keychain ring for easy portability.

It has a 9mm diameter, making it suitable for cigars with a ring gauge of up to 50. Despite its affordable price, the Mantello Cigar Punch is durable and effective, making it a great choice for budget-conscious cigar enthusiasts.

What do cigar enthusiasts on Reddit say about the best cigar punches?

Cigar enthusiasts on Reddit have a wide range of opinions on the best cigar punches. Some popular options include the Xikar Xi1 Punch, the Colibri V-Cut Cigar Cutter, and the S.T. Dupont MaxiJet Punch.

Many users also recommend trying out different types of punches to find the one that works best for your personal preferences and smoking style.