Best Cigarillo Brands – Unveiling the Finest Selections of 2024

Picture of Justin R.
Justin R.

Cigar Enthusiast, Chief Editor

best cigarillo brands
Table of Contents

I’ve been lighting up the best cigarillo brands for more than a decade, and it’s been a ride full of rich aromas and unforgettable moments.

I personally love the Macunudo Cafe Ascot, from the smooth draw of a well-crafted blend to the ambiance it creates, they have become more than just a quick smoke break; they’re a testament to taste and tradition.

Drawing on my years of experience, I’m about to drop the lowdown on the crème de la crème of 2023’s cigarillo selections.

Whether it’s the nostalgic whiff of a Dutch Master or the bold statement of Backwoods Cigars, I’ve puffed my way through the array to give you a straight-shooting guide to the top-shelf picks.

We’re talking the best-selling cigarillo brands that have stood the test of time, as well as the newcomers that are shaking up the scene. So buckle up, as we explore my favorite cigarillo brands and what makes them stand out in this smoky sphere.

Unraveling the Legacy of Cigarillo Brands

The cigarillo universe is rich with stories, with brands like Dutch Masters and Backwoods Cigars writing chapters that have shaped the culture of smoking. Game Cigars and Optimo Cigars also deserve a shout-out for their contributions.

These brands have been cradling tobacco leaves into masterpieces, creating flavor profiles that resonate with both seasoned aficionados and those new to the dance.

Let’s spark up a little historical context as we delve into how these legacy brands became stitched into the fabric of our smoking heritage.

A Brief History of Cigarillos in the American Market

Back in the 19th century, when pocket watches were a flex and horse-drawn carriages were the whip of choice, cigarillos already began whispering their affordable smoking charm across America.

They were the everyman’s escape, a brief respite from the daily grind without the commitment of a full-sized cigar.

The likes of Dutch Masters stepped onto the scene, curating tobacco with flavor profiles that echoed the diversity of America itself.

These little flavor bombs provided a convenient and satisfying experience that, over time, became stitched into the nation’s cultural tapestry.

Leading Cigarillo Brands of the Year

Dutch Masters, Backwoods Cigars, and their ilk continue to dominate the packs, proving that quality, consistency, and killer flavor profiles keep smokers coming back.

As for this year’s heavy hitters, I’ve personally sampled the goods and can vouch for the top-tier satisfaction they deliver.

Get ready to meet the all-stars of 2023 that are setting fire to the expectations of what a cigarillo can truly offer the discerning smoker.

Macanudo Cafe Ascot

Macanudo Cafe Ascot

Ever had something so good it feels like your taste buds are throwing a party? That’s the Macanudo Cafe Ascot for you. These guys come in a tidy 4 x 32 size, perfect when you’re stepping out and time is tighter than a new pair of shoes.

Mild, creamy, and with a flawless burn, I stand by these cigarillos as some of the best companions for the everyday hustle.

Macanudo’s always sitting at the big table in the cigar world for a reason, and these Ascots prove it every time I spark one up.

Acid Krush Classic Blue Connecticut 5/10

Acid Krush Classic Blue Connecticut 5/10

Now, when Acid gets in the mix, you know it’s not your granddaddy’s smoke we’re talking about.

Packed in tins that are perfect for the on-the-go life, Krush Classic Blues with their Connecticut Shade wrapper bring a certain spunk to the table.

With a smoke that spills out smooth with a bit of sweet, it’s like Acid took their signature series, dialed it to a ten, and sized it down just enough to fit into your coffee break.

This little number doesn’t just talk the talk—it walks the walk with every puff.

Davidoff Mini Cigarillo Gold 10/10

Davidoff Mini Cigarillo Gold 10/10

Let me tell you about Davidoff Mini Cigarillo Gold—they’re like a luxury sports car in cigarillo form. Hailing from that famous smoke shop, it feels like you’ve joined an exclusive club when you light one of these up.

A box of 60 packs enough gold to share with your buddies, or keep for those ‘treat yourself’ moments.

For cigar smokers looking for something elegant without the hours-long commitment, pop open a tin of these and watch time slow down for just the right amount of enjoyment.

Avo Classic Puritos 10/10

Avo Classic Puritos 10/10

Fancy something that hits the mark every time? Avo Classic Puritos, right out the gate, are a smooth operator. It’s like rolling out a red carpet for your senses—packaged in tins that say class with every flick of the lid.

The creaminess of that Connecticut Shade wrapper tied to the signature series blend? It’s harmonious, like watching an orchestra where every note is played to perfection. It’s high time you gave these little classics a home in your stash.

Ashton Small Cigars Senoritas Connecticut 10/10

Ashton Small Cigars Senoritas Connecticut 10/10

On a quest for small-size nobility? Ashton Small Cigars Senoritas are my knights in shining armor. They ride in with a Connecticut wrap that’s prime real estate in flavor town.

And marketing fluff aside, when I crack open a box of 100, it’s an invitation to class without the hefty price tag. Drop by that famous smoke shop and snag these Senoritas.

Before you know it, you’ll be stockpiling these beauties for those ‘queen and king for a day’ moments.

Premium Cigarillo Choices for Connoisseurs

Heads up, high rollers! We’re now striding into territory where only the most sophisticated of tastes dare to tread. These premium cigarillo choices are like a private jazz club for your palate—exclusive, mood-setting, and a bit trance-inducing.

I’m talking about those elegant sticks that carry a legacy as deep as their flavor, and ones that every bonafide cigar smoker worth their salt should try at least once. Buckle up; we’re about to take a walk on the refined side!

Davidoff Signature Exquisitos: Luxurious Perfection

Let’s raise the stakes with Davidoff Signature Exquisitos—opulence in a box of 20. These 3 x 22 mini marvels are like diamonds, precious and pristine in their craft. The flavors and aromas? They’re the stuff of legend, my friends.

Medium-bodied, yet exuding subtlety that’ll have you tipping your hat in respect. It’s the kind of cigarillo you stash away for the milestones or when ordinary simply won’t cut it. Davidoff doesn’t just set the bar; they own it.

Arturo Fuente Exquisitos Maduro: Rich and Robust

Step up to the plate if you fancy something with a little more muscle. Arturo Fuente Exquisitos Maduro’s got your back with a bold Connecticut Broadleaf Maduro wrap that brings the house down.

In a 4 x 33 size, packed in tins of 10, these aren’t just cigarillos—they’re flavor bombs waiting to be detonated. Light one up and get hit with a flavor that’s rich, earthy, all-out robust—all the while nodding to the Fuente empire of taste.

Sold individually, these are the treats you don’t have to share unless you’re feeling generous.

Ashton Classic Cigarillos: Elegantly Crafted

Let me bend your ear about Ashton Classic Cigarillos—the bows and ribbons of the cigarillo world. When you fancy something nuanced yet mellow, these beauties deliver in spades.

Courtesy of Famous Smoke, they slide into a 3 x 26 size that’s easy to tote around. It’s a different blend from the big Ashton Classic, but the family resemblance is unmistakable.

One puff and you’re nodding, thinking, ‘Yeah, this is what refinement tastes like.’

Joya de Nicaragua Joya Red: Bold and Flavorful

Ready for a cigarillo that packs a wallop? Joya de Nicaragua Joya Red does just that with a Nicaraguan kick that’ll have your palate singing. In a 4 x 32 tin of 50, these little powerhouses are the ones you reach for when you need a kickstart.

Bringing notes of nuttiness, pepper, and spice, it’s about as close as you get to a high-octane experience without leaving your chair. The flair of Nicaragua without the airfare? Sign me up!

La Flor Dominicana Little Cigars: Petite Powerhouses

And for the grand finale, La Flor Dominicana Little Cigars. In the mini cigarillos league, these fellas are heavy hitters. The 3 x 28 size might be compact, but the experience? It’s anything but.

One hit and you’re tasting that signature La Flor punch—coffee, earth, a hint of honey berry madness.

Whether it’s Russian Cream or Wild Rum you’re chasing, or a throwback to Middleton’s Cherry Blend, these cigarillos bring the heat and the sweet, all at once—dominion in the palm of your hand.

The Top Picks for Discerning Smokers

If you’re picky about your smokes like I am, you want that perfect blend of flavor and tradition. That’s why I’m bringing you the cream of the crop—the cigarillos that have made a mark this year and won’t disappoint.

Partagas Puritos: The Heritage Brand

Now, if it’s heritage you’re after, look no further than Partagas Puritos. With a heritage as rich as their flavors, these Puritos offer a robust smoking experience complete with wood and spice notes, with cedarwood leading the parade.

Sized up from the Partagas Miniatures, they hit the sweet spot for size and speed, giving you a full experience in a shorter time.

Romeo y Julieta 1875 Julietas: A Romantic Smoke

Talking about a romantic smoke, Romeo y Julieta 1875 Julietas don’t just have a seductive name; they back it up with quality Dominican tobacco wrapped in a perfect cigarillo size at 4 x 28.

Consistent in flavor and aroma, and priced for a steal, they’re a no-brainer for folks looking to add a little romance to their smoke time.

Montecristo White Series Prontos Petites: The Epitome of Sophistication

Looking to up the ante on sophistication? The Montecristo White Series Prontos Petites won’t let you down. These little guys pack the same punch as their larger siblings, all neatly packaged in tins of six.

Their smooth creaminess is a surefire hit, making them a perfect choice for those moments that call for something a notch above.

Where to Purchase Your Preferred Cigarillos

Now that you’ve got your eyes on some top-notch cigarillos, you’re probably itching to know where to snag ’em. Keep on reading, because I’ve got some spots in mind that’ll get you what you need without the fuss.

Streamlining Your Cigarillo Shopping Experience

As a veteran in the cigar world, I’ve seen plenty of new cigar smokers and seasoned pros seeking out that quick, flavorful smoke.

The key? Finding a shop that gets it. Famous Smoke Shop does it right with a massive selection and deals you won’t want to skip.

How to Choose the Right Online Retailer

When you’re hunting down the best cigarillos, it all starts with picking the right retailer.

A spot that’s got a wide range of cigar brands, keeps tabs on what’s hot and what’s not, and offers those sweet prices that make you feel like you’re getting away with something. That’s the ticket to a happy smoke.

Secure Payment Methods for Cigarillo Purchases

Let’s talk turkey here—when you’re buying your little bundles of joy, you better make sure your cash is going the safe route.

Look for online sellers that take security as seriously as you take your first draw of the day—encrypted transactions, the works.

Ensuring Freshness and Quality Upon Delivery

There’s nothing worse than waiting for that box of joy, only to find your smokes tasting like they’ve been on a world tour twice over.

Go with sellers who treat those cigarillos like the treasures they are, keeping them fresh and snug until they land in your eager hands—or better yet, your humidor.

Savor the Experience: A Closing Thought on Selecting the Best Cigarillo Brands

The world of cigarillos can be as complex and varied as that of their big brothers, the premium cigars.

In my decade-long journey in the cigar industry, I’ve seen trends come and go, but the joy of finding that perfect cigarillo hasn’t changed since I sparked up my first stick at 20.

It’s not just about the legacy brands like Dutch Masters and the bold flavors of Backwoods Cigars; it’s about the experience each slender roll of tobacco brings to your day.

Whether it’s 10 cigarillos from a tin of 30 for a quick smoke break or leisurely puffing on a Game Cigar, the choice is all about the profile that suits your palate.

For me, the favorites are those that carry a certain depth, like those wrapped in a Cameroon wrapper or filled with that robust Dominican and Nicaraguan filler tobacco.

Yet for others, the fruity flavor of a berry fusion or the distinct taste of honey bourbon can define an entire smoking experience.

The choices in the cigar world are many, and my advice is to explore them, from the Optimo Cigars’ smooth draw to the rich smoke of 4 Kings Cigarillos.

When it’s about selecting the best cigarillo brands on the market today, trust your taste buds, and remember, each puff tells a story of regions, from the Dominican Republic to the craft of cigarillo makers worldwide.