7 Best Mild Cigars That Beginners Should Try First

Updated: 2024

While many people like to opt for a strong darker cigar, light and mild cigars still have a lot to offer. What’s more, there are various mild cigars for beginners that are worth checking out. Even if you’re a long-standing cigar smoker, you can still enjoy milder cigars if you choose the right ones.

Personally, I find the Camacho Connecticut Churchill to be the best mild cigar if you’re a new smoker.

It has a mild spicy flavor, but still sticks to its original Camacho taste, offering a pleasant cigar smoking experience. 

Continue reading below to learn about the best mild cigars that are perfect for beginner cigar smokers.

We’ll also touch a bit on what to look for when choosing a mild cigar, so you can make the right choice every time.

Sam H.
Sam H.

Cigar Enthusiast

mild beginner Camacho Connecticut Churchill

TOP CHOICE

Camacho Connecticut Churchill

  • Fine blend of long fillers
  • Silky-smooth Ecuadorian Connecticut wrappers
  • Mild spicy flavor
 

The silky-smooth Ecuadorian Connecticut wrappers are what hold the Camacho Churchill together, offering a more pleasant smoking experience.

CAO Gold Torpedo

mild beginner CAO Gold Torpedo
  • Aroma of spice, herbs, and other botanicals
  • Connecticut wrapper
  • Nicaraguan tobacco

Oliva Connecticut Reserve Churchill

  • Budget-friendly
  • Earthy, nutty flavors
  • Nicaraguan tobaccos
Best Mild Cigars For Beginners

Camacho Connecticut Churchill (Best Mild Cigar For Beginner)

mild beginner Camacho Connecticut Churchill
  • Strength: Medium
  • Country: Honduras
  • Wrapper: Connecticut Shade
  • Shape: Churchill
  • Flavor: Spicy
  • Suitable for: New Smokers
 

Camacho cigars are known for being quite rough (in a good way), as they tend to be full bodied fine cigars packed with immense flavor. However, the Camacho Connecticut Churchill was spawned due to countless requests for the brand to make a cigar that’s more on the mild side.

The Camacho Connecticut Churchill contains a fine blend of long fillers from the Dominican Republic and Honduras.

The silky-smooth Ecuadorian Connecticut wrappers are what hold the Camacho Churchill together, offering a more pleasant cigar smoking experience.

What I like most about this cigar is that it has a mild spicy flavor, but still sticks to its original Camacho taste. Beginner cigar smokers can use the Camacho Connecticut Churchill as an introductory stick, and eventually work their way up to strong fine cigars.

Measuring in at a whopping 7 inches and 48 ring gauge, you can light this quality cigar and spend a great deal of time enjoying its flavor profile.

No doubt, it’s one of the best fine cigars if you’re looking for flavor without the intense strength.

CAO Gold Torpedo (Best Burn)

mild beginner CAO Gold Torpedo
  • Strength: Mild
  • Country: Nicaragua
  • Wrapper: Ecuador/Connecticut
  • Shape: Torpedo
  • Flavor: Spicy/Mellow
  • Suitable for: Long Smoking Sessions
 

The CAO Gold Torpedo is one of the most popular flavored cigars on the market. 

It produces such a pleasant aroma of spice, herbs, and other botanicals.

The Ecuadorian Connecticut shade wrapper and Nicaraguan tobacco create such a silky, smooth smoke. In fact, I’d go as far as to say that CAO Flavours makes the best use out of the Connecticut wrapper.

The overall construction of this cigar is outstanding.

I personally enjoy the earthy and subtle spice flavors, which is tough to find even in high quality cigars.

Out of all the cigars out there, the mellow flavors are extremely prevalent in the CAO Gold Torpedo. It has the taste of an expensive cigar without the high price tag.

The complex flavors are the result of the high quality Nicaraguan long filler combined with the spicy Connecticut wrapper. The mild profile makes it an excellent starting cigar to warm up a beginner’s palate.

If you’re looking for a suitable first cigar to get you into the culture, then you can’t go wrong with the Gold Torpedo by CAO Flavours.

Oliva Connecticut Reserve Churchill (Best Value for Money)

  • Strength: Mellow
  • Country: Nicaragua
  • Wrapper: Connecticut Shade
  • Shape: Churchill
  • Flavor: Creamy
  • Suitable for: Smoking On A Budget
 

If you’re a beginner cigar smoker looking for a high quality cigar on a budget, then look no further than the Oliva Connecticut Reserve Churchill.

While it may not be the cheapest cigar on the market, it’s the best quality you can get within its price range.

I might be a little bias as I’m a sucker for earthy, nutty flavors.

However, it’s safe to say that most people would consider this the right cigar if you’re on a budget.

The creamy flavor notes from the Nicaraguan tobaccos are incredibly smooth. Meanwhile the Connecticut wrapper is extremely mellow and mild.

If you’re a fan of coffee notes, then you’ll absolutely enjoy this cigar by Oliva Connecticut Reserve. The Churchills are by no means small cigars, so you will need some time to finish this stick. It’s an excellent choice for smoking in a lounge or at a barbeque where you have time to relax.

Macanudo Cafe Baron De Rothschild (Best Aroma)

mild beginner Macanudo Cafe Baron De Rothschild
  • Strength: Mellow
  • Country: Dominican Republic
  • Wrapper: Connecticut Shade
  • Shape: Lonsdale
  • Flavor: Creamy
  • Suitable for: Smoking Indoors
 

Seasoned cigar smokers will tell you that aromas are a fundamental part of cigars. Not only does the aroma impact the taste, but it will also determine the overall cigar smoking experience you get from a stogie.

Aromas is where the Macanudo Cafe Baron De Rothschild is an absolute winner.

Out of all the beginner cigars, this one provides the most pleasant aroma a cigar can offer.

The creamy flavors are also amazing, and match those you get from premium cigars. Moreover, the smoke is incredibly light. As a result, beginner smokers won’t get such a harsh feeling in their throat.

The Connecticut shade wrapper holds the binder and filler tobacco blend together quite well. The stick burns incredibly smooth, making it easier to enjoy than other mellow or medium bodied cigar.

Overall, it’s a great cigar if you’re looking to savor the sweet cigar smell. Even non-smokers will likely enjoy the aroma this stick omits.

Arturo Fuente Churchill Claro (Best Cigar for Relaxing)

mild beginner Arturo Fuente Churchill Claro
  • Strength: Medium
  • Country: Dominican Republic
  • Wrapper: Connecticut Shade
  • Shape: Churchill
  • Flavor: Light
  • Suitable for: Smoking With Coffee
 

Arturo Fuente is a reputable brand notorious for producing some of the best cigars in circulation.

The Arturo Fuente Churchill Claro is one of their lighter, milder cigars you can get your hands on.

This cigar is hand wrapped using some of the finest tobacco from the Dominican Republic, which adds to its overall feel and taste.

It’s an excellent choice if you’re looking for a first cigar from a dependable brand. Arturo Fuente doesn’t miss, and the Churchill Claro is no exception.

The bright green Claro wrapper truly makes this cigar stand out from the other darker colored ones. With such a wrapper, the Arturo Fuente offers a lighter taste, making it one of the top mild beginner cigars.

If it’s your first time trying an Arturo Fuente cigar, I recommend going with the Churchill Claro. It’s thick and will take a while to finish, but the light smoke will make this stick super enjoyable.

Cohiba Connecticut Gigante (Best Thick Cigar)

mild beginner Cohiba Connecticut Gigante
  • Strength: Medium
  • Country: Dominican Republic
  • Wrapper: Connecticut Shade
  • Shape: Gigante
  • Flavor: Silky
  • Suitable for: Intermediate Cigar Smokers
 

Cohiba is another brand that’s well-known in the cigar industry and in pop culture.

The Cohiba Connecticut collection is the first time Cohiba has ever wrapped their cigars using an Ecuadorian Connecticut shade wrapper. The Gigante is the largest of the line, with an impressive 6 inch length and 60 ring gauge.

Needless to say, this cigar is incredibly thick.

The Dominican Republic tobacco is absolutely delicious, and creates an incredibly mild smoke.

The Gigante is a fantastic choice for beginner cigar smokers because it has a smooth draw and will burn without effort. The only stick that can compare is maybe the Ashton Classic. It’s perhaps the best medium bodied cigar available at this price.

One thing that may be a dealbreaker with the Cohiba Connecticut Gigante is the price. They are quite expensive when compared to other cigars available. Moreover, they can be tricky to find at your local cigar shop or even national chains. Luckily, you can find Gigantes online for a reasonable price.

La Aroma De Cuba Edición Especial No.3

mild beginner La Aroma De Cuba Edición Especial No.3
  • Strength: Medium
  • Country: Nicaragua wrapper
  • Wrapper: Habano
  • Shape: Toro
  • Flavor: Classic Tobacco
  • Suitable for: Special Occasions
 

Last but certainly not least, we have the Edicion Especial No.3 cigar from La Aroma De Cuba.

For starters, La Aroma de Cuba is well-known for producing high-quality Cuban-like tobacco that they use for their best cigars.

With that, we have the incredibly smooth Edicion Especial No.3. It’s a cigar that you can smoke on practically any occasion, and always feel like you’re on top of the world.

In terms of taste, the La Aroma de Cuba Edicion Especial No.3 outshines flavored stogies from Macanudo Cafe and CAO Flavours.

One thing I really love about this cigar is the build quality.

You can feel the passion and focus that went into your cigar right when you take it out of the packaging. It’s the kind of stogie you would smoke after graduation or on your wedding night.

The beautiful Habano wrapper leaf adds such a nice touch to the cigar’s body. Furthermore, there are zero protruding veins throughout the cigar. Having no veins as a sun-grown cigar is almost unheard of.

How To Choose Your First Cigar

Finding the perfect first cigar is easier said than done.

There are numerous factors and options to choose from, which can create a massive headache if you don’t know what to look for. However, try and stay positive and remember how lucky you are.

I’d give anything to go back to the moment where I was choosing my first box of stogies. It’s an exciting time, so try your best to have fun in the process.

Here are some few tips to help you choose the best cigar possible, and make sure you always pick good cigars every time you shop at local shops and national chains.

 

1. Understanding Cigar Sizes

For the beginner smoker, all the different cigar sizes can be intimidating. To add insult to injury, there are several factors that go into a cigar’s size. Before you get smoked trying to learn the lingo, remember the two components that matter:

  1. Length
  2. Ring Gauge
 

In short, the ring gauge measures the thickness in 64ths of an inch and length is self-explanatory. The higher the ring gauge, the thicker the cigar. Most stogies are roughly 5-7 inches long and have a ring gauge of 40-50.

Here are some of the common cigar sizes (from smallest to largest)

  • Cigarillo
  • Petit Corona
  • Gordito
  • Corona
  • Toro
  • Lonsdale
  • Churchill
  • Double Corona
  • Gran Corona
 

However, cigar size doesn’t necessarily determine strength or nicotine content. It only really shows how long they take to finish. Longer cigars need more time to be smoked, where thinner cigars will burn faster.

 

2. Cigar Shapes 101

If cigar sizes are stressing you out, don’t be too worried about shape. In general, there are only two cigar shapes: the parejo and and figurado.

Parejos are the classic cigar shapes with rounded caps and cylinder sides. The figurado cigars are famous for their pointed caps and peculiar shape.

Many cigar makers produce parejos simply because they are far easier to roll than figurados. However, there is a niche market of figurado lovers. Many cigar enthusiasts claim that the pointed caps give the cigars more taste and smoke better.

That said, I’d recommend starting with a classic parejo cigar and focus more on the kind of tobacco inside.

 

3. Cigar Anatomy

Knowing the composition of a cigar is an essential step for beginners, as it makes it easier to read product descriptions on cigar sites or in stores. In essence, all you need to know are:

  • Size
  • Strength and Body
  • Layers
 

Since we’ve already covered cigar sizes, let’s start with strength and body.

Most cigars are labeled as mild (sometimes called mellow), medium bodied cigar, or full bodied.

All this really means is the flavor density. These cigars will still be packed with flavor notes, but they won’t be as intense. A medium bodied cigar sit in the middle with full bodied stogies being the strongest.

If you smoke a full bodied cigar, you can feel a rush of savors and aromas hitting your palate. Most beginners find these cigars to be too intense, so they would be better off going with a mild blend.

Strength determines the amount of nicotine in the cigar. Local tobacconist and cigar stores generally have all the information about their stogies in clear view. Understanding these terms will make finding the fight smoke much easier.

Finally, we have the three cigar layers:

  • Filler Tobacco. The filler tobacco makes up the core of the cigar, and typically contains pressed broken tobacco leaves.
  • Binder Leaf. The binder leaf is the middle layer of the cigar that holds the filler tobacco in place. Usually, the binder contains the same blend as the filler, but the leaves are left unbroken.
  • Wrapper Leaf. The wrapper leaf, perhaps the most important layer, is the outer part of the cigar that holds everything together and gives cigars their unique appearance.
 

FAQs

 

What Is the Mildest Cigar for Beginners?

The mildest cigar for beginners would either be the Macanudo Cafe Baron De Rothschild or Ashton Classic. The Macanudo Cafe has a creamy coffee taste that’s easy on the throat. With the Ashton Classic, you get an extremely mild smoke along with an excellent aroma.

 

Which Cigar Is Good for Beginners?

As you can see from the list above, there are numerous cigars for beginners that taste amazing and are easy to smoke. 

Some of the top cigars for beginners come from top brands like Ashton Classic, Arturo Fuente, Romeo Y Julieta, and more.

If you’re looking to smoke your first few cigars, be sure to go with a mild stogie at first. These cigars are easier on the throat, and allow you to get a feel for how to puff on your stick. Eventually you can work your way up to more premium cigars once you develop your palate.

 

What Are Mild Cigars Called?

These type of cigars define stogies that are lighter in flavor. You may see cigars listed as “light”, “mild”, or “mellow”, and those all generally mean the flavor intensity is relatively low.

 

Can Dark Cigars Be Mild?

Like with coffee, our minds can trick us into thinking darker means stronger. While it’s true that darker cigars are usually stronger, that doesn’t mean that all dark cigars are strong. There are various mild maduro cigars that are suitable for beginners.

Always check the details in the cigar shop or online store to see what strength the cigars are labeled as.

 

How Do You Know if a Cigar Is Mild?

Let’s say you walk into a cigar shop looking for a mild stogie, but can’t tell which ones are light or packed with flavor. In that case, the best way is to ask the owner of the shop to point you in the right direction.

You can always ask another fellow cigar enthusiasts for which cigars for beginners they’d recommend. Most cigar smokers are more than happy to give you their opinion.

Verdict

The cigar I recommend for beginners to try is definitely the Camacho Connecticut Churchill.

It’s great as a introductory stick before you eventually work your way up to strong cigars.

Finding the top light cigars for beginners is now a little easier with the list above.

You can check through each option to see if any match your flavor preferences.

Remember, make sure you understand the cigar aficionado lingo. It will help you choose the best cigars for beginners, and throughout your entire career as a cigar smoker.

Once you get past smoking cigars for beginners, you can graduate to stronger and finer stogies.